What Airlines Don’t Tell You About Carbon Offsetting

{{ vm.tagsGroup }}

19 Jun 2025

8 Min Read

Mr Nantha Gopal Muniandy (Academic Contributor)

IN THIS ARTICLE
Mr Nantha Gopal Muniandy

Contributed by Mr Nantha Gopal Muniandy. He can be reached at nanthagopal.muniandy@taylors.edu.my.

You’ve just booked your dream getaway. As you check out, a small option appears: Offset your carbon emissions for just 15 Ringgit. It feels like the responsible thing to do—pay a small fee, and your flight becomes ‘carbon neutral.’ The environment wins, and so do you. Or so it seems.

 

Carbon offsetting has become aviation’s favourite climate solution. Airlines increasingly promote it as a way to fly guilt-free, offering passengers the option to invest in eco-friendly projects that supposedly cancel out their emissions. But the reality behind these schemes is far more complicated. If you’ve ever wondered whether these offsets actually work, or whether airlines are telling you the full story, it’s time to take a closer look.

How Carbon Offsetting Works

The idea behind carbon offsetting is straightforward: for every tonne of carbon dioxide (CO₂) a person or company emits, they can pay to fund a project elsewhere that either removes or avoids that same amount of CO₂. This might involve planting trees, installing wind turbines, or preserving rainforests.

 

In the context of air travel, airlines often incorporate carbon offsetting into the ticketing process. Passengers are encouraged to pay a little extra to support these green projects, usually through third-party partnerships. Some airlines, like British Airways, offer passengers the chance to fund clean cooking stove initiatives in Africa and South America—schemes designed to reduce wood-burning emissions.

 

In 2023, Malaysia Airlines has also taken a notable step by launching the country’s first voluntary carbon offset programme, allowing both individual and corporate customers to calculate and offset the emissions associated with their flights. Customers are then given the option to support internationally certified carbon reduction projects aligned with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals.

Empty air plane seats

There’s no global standard for calculating the carbon footprint of a flight—which means the same journey can have different emission estimates depending on the airline, carbon calculator, or methodology used. Some calculators factor in only the direct fuel burn for your seat, while others include radiative forcing—the additional warming effect of emissions at high altitudes, which can nearly double the climate impact. For example, flying at cruising altitude releases nitrogen oxides and causes contrail formation, both of which can trap heat in the atmosphere more than CO₂ alone.

The Green Illusion: Marketing vs Reality

While carbon offsetting sounds noble, many experts have warned that the practice can easily cross into greenwashing—a term used when companies make misleading claims about their environmental impact. A good example is Ryanair, which marketed itself as a low-emission airline thanks to its offsetting programme, despite being one of Europe’s top polluters.

 

Even more concerning is the lack of oversight. In 2023, Delta Air Lines was scrutinised after research found that its offset claims were overestimated by up to 40%. Passengers who believed they were flying ‘carbon neutral’ were, in fact, misled. The problem is compounded by the fact that many offsetting schemes are not independently verified, and the industry lacks strict regulatory frameworks.

Forest

One of the most common types of offset projects involves tree planting. It’s easy to see the appeal: forests absorb CO₂, and planting trees seems like an act of restoration. But there’s a catch—trees take years, even decades, to mature and absorb significant amounts of carbon. The emissions from your flight, however, are released immediately. The timeline simply doesn’t add up.

What You Can Do to Travel More Sustainably

While offsetting can support some useful projects, it shouldn’t be treated as a silver bullet. There are more direct ways for travellers to reduce their environmental impact.

 

First, consider flying smarter. Direct flights are more efficient than those with multiple stopovers because take-off and landing consume the most fuel. Economy class seating also results in lower emissions per person, as more passengers share the same flight. Simply choosing your route and seat wisely can make a noticeable difference.

Sustainability awareness is rising, especially among Gen Z and Millennials, but cost and convenience still drive most flight decisions. While some are willing to offset emissions or choose rail, true change needs affordable, accessible alternatives, and clearer environmental costs.

— Mr Nantha Gopal Muniandy

Another promising development in aviation is sustainable aviation fuel (SAF). Unlike fossil-based jet fuel, SAF is produced from renewable sources like waste oils, plant materials, or even algae. It can reduce carbon emissions by up to 80% over its lifecycle. Although not yet widely available, SAF is gaining traction. In Malaysia, Malaysia Airlines has partnered with PETRONAS to accelerate SAF development, aiming to turn the country into a regional hub for green aviation fuel. AirAsia, too, is working with Airbus on decentralised SAF production, exploring alternative materials and processes to scale up adoption.

A Nippon Airline

Even something as simple as packing lighter can help. A lighter aircraft burns less fuel, which directly reduces emissions. For instance, All Nippon Airways (ANA) implemented a weight reduction initiative by introducing lighter in-flight service carts, achieving a weight reduction of up to 10 kg per cart. This change resulted in a total weight reduction of approximately 580 kg per Boeing 777-300ER aircraft, leading to an annual fuel consumption reduction of about 5,700 tonnes and a corresponding decrease in CO₂ emissions.

Conclusion

The next time you see a carbon offset box at checkout, pause and ask yourself: Is this solving the problem, or simply pushing it down the road?

 

Flying responsibly isn’t about ticking a box—it’s about rethinking how we travel, and what kind of future we want to support. Offset programmes can be part of the picture, but only if they’re transparent, regulated, and part of a broader strategy to cut emissions at the source.

 

If you're passionate about sustainability, climate solutions, or the future of tourism, this is more than just a travel decision—it could be the start of a career in shaping global change.

Start with a Foundation in Arts and explore your path into International Tourism Management. Learn how the travel industry is evolving—and how you can be part of making it greener, smarter, and more sustainable.

YOU MIGHT BE INTERESTED
{{ item.articleDate ? vm.formatDate(item.articleDate) : '' }}
{{ item.readTime }} Min Read